A Good Girl’s Guide To Murder’s Villain Twist Hits Much Harder After Prime Video’s 2024 Romance Show With 94% On RT (2025)

FAQs

Who killed Sal in A Good Girl's Guide to Murder? ›

Elliot confessed to Isla that he was the one who killed Sal. He admitted to drugging Sal first before smothering him. After hearing this, the girl tried to escape, but Elliot wouldn't let her go.

The season ends with Pip connecting all the dots and looking into one final loose end after Elliot's arrest: Becca Bell. She heads over to the Bell residence where Becca tells her what happened the night Andie died, and offers to take Pip to the woods to show her where she dumped her sister's body.

The revelation about Sal is impactful, but the actual uncovering of Andie's killer might not sit well with all viewers. A Good Girl's Guide to Murder is a decent detective series that offers an intriguing story, well-written characters, and solid performances, especially from Emma Myers.

Becca Bell Killed Pip's Dog Barney In A Good Girl's Guide To Murder.

There were two main culprits behind Andie's (India Lillie Davis) death — her teacher and former lover Elliot Ward (Mathew Baynton) and her sister Becca (Carla Woodcock), who both played an individual role in her tragic demise.

The book has some strong language that may not be suitable for younger kids and has many mentions of sex and drugs, so I would recommend this book to people 14 and up.

And it does, of course, take her to dangerous places. As I mentioned, the good news is, Pippa's best friend Cara (Asha Banks) is queer. The bad news is, despite them regularly holding hands, and generally being quite cuddly, sadly Pippa is not her girlfriend. You can see how I thought, briefly, that they were a thing.

Sex & Nudity (4)

Male torso and female in underwear is seen briefly in some episodes. There is a mild kiss scene between two characters. In the background of a party a fully clothed couple can be seen thrusting. Very brief and not graphic.

Salil Singh was accused of murdering Andie Bell, the former's girlfriend. Elliot Ward, his history teacher, was Sal's murderer.

After hearing Andie had gone missing he presumed he would be found guilty of murder (which he kinda was) and so he looked for someone else to blame it on. He framed Sal for Andie's murder, sending a text from his phone and then smothered Sal to death to make it appear as if Sal had committed suicide.

Who is the real murder in A Good Girl's Guide to murder? ›

Becca, Andie's sister, confesses that Max Hastings had drugged and raped her - with rohypnol sold to him by Andie. In anger, Becca pushed Andie, who fell, convulsed and died.

But Pippa wholeheartedly believes this to be untrue, and eventually realizes that Sal was also murdered. In the finale, Pippa discovers that the atrocious act was committed by Elliot Ward (Matthew Baynton, known for his role in Ghosts UK), her English teacher and her best friend's father.